Expert witness reports are vital evidence in every aspect of a drugs and/or money laundering case. Therefore, the defence should not prima facie accept the accuracy and/ or reliability of the contents and conclusions.  It is imperative to check whether the the expert has complied with the procedural rules, identify errors in the analysis and conclusions and then challenge the expert witness. 

Steps to take when considering a prosecution expert witness report;  

Review the report thoroughly:

The first step in challenging an expert witness report is to review it thoroughly, looking for any errors, inconsistencies, or biases in the report. Has the expert followed all the required rules, directions, guidance, policies and procedures? 

Instruct other experts:

Get a second opinion on the report. This can help to identify any errors or biases in the report. Any expert witness worthy of their salt will always embrace scrutiny, and those that do not are those in most need of the scrutiny.

Cross-examine the expert witness:

During the trial, cross-examine the expert witness to challenge their evidence. This can involve asking questions about their methodologies, their qualifications, training, experience, their understanding of the role and the responsibilities as well as any biases they may exist.

Present alternative evidence:

You may also want to present alternative evidence that contradicts the findings within the expert report. Viable and credible alternate theories and interpretations of the evidence that have not previously been considered. This can undermine the credibility of the report and the expert witness.

Make an application to exclude the report:

If the expert witness report is unreliable or biased, or if the expert witness has failed in their duties then their evidence should be excluded. This can prevent the report from being used as evidence in the case.

Challenging a vital expert witness report can be a critical to the outcome of a defence case. By reviewing the report thoroughly, consulting with other experts, cross-examining the witness, presenting alternative evidence, and filing an application to exclude the report, you can help to ensure that justice is served.

Require legal help? Get in contact with one of our criminal law team to see how we can help you, either enquiries@garricklaw.com or call us on +44 (0)203 196 7822.

Visit our Criminal Law page to read how Garrick Law can support you today.